House
10.0(14 Reviews)
2 Bedrooms
4 Guests
Parking
Ocean View
Balcony/Terrace
View
US $496/Night
7 Nights - US $3,470
Brookhaven Holiday Rentals
We compare holiday rentals from owners across Booking.com, Vrbo and Expedia.
- Up-front pricing
- No markup
- Trusted partners
Compare Villas, Resorts, & Rentals in Brookhaven
10.0
House
10.0(1 Review)
5 Bedrooms
15 Guests
Oceanfront
Hot Tub
Breakfast- Parking
US $982/Night
7 Nights - US $6,872
US $437/Night
7 Nights - US $3,059
House
9.8(10 Reviews)
2 Bedrooms
5 Guests
Private Pool- Parking
Pool- Balcony/Terrace
US $186/Night
7 Nights - US $1,302
Apartment
6.1(11 Reviews)
2 Bedrooms
4 Guests
- Breakfast
- Parking
- Balcony/Terrace
- View
US $199/Night
7 Nights - US $1,395
Apartment
9.4(3 Reviews)
2 Bedrooms
5 Guests
- Oceanfront
- Parking
- Pool
- Ocean View
US $323/Night
7 Nights - US $2,259
Apartment
9.4(3 Reviews)
1 Bedroom
4 Guests
Air Conditioner
Internet
Pet Friendly
Child Friendly
US $299/Night
7 Nights - US $2,095
House
9.2(17 Reviews)
2 Bedrooms
5 Guests
- Oceanfront
- Parking
- Ocean View
- Balcony/Terrace
US $674/Night
7 Nights - US $4,721
Apartment
8.0(21 Reviews)
2 Bedrooms
4 Guests
- Parking
- Balcony/Terrace
Kitchen- Air Conditioner
US $170/Night
7 Nights - US $1,191
Luxury Holiday Rentals in Brookhaven
Over 134+ Luxury Holiday Rentals in or Near Brookhaven
House
10.0(1 Review)
5 Bedrooms
13 Guests
- Private Pool
- Hot Tub
- Pool
- Ocean View
US $4,338/Night
7 Nights - US $30,365
House
5 Bedrooms
- Air Conditioner
- Internet
Laundry
Bedding/Linens
US $2,349/Night
7 Nights - US $16,440
House
9.4(3 Reviews)
4 Bedrooms
8 Guests
- Private Pool
- Parking
- Pool
- Ocean View
US $2,217/Night
7 Nights - US $15,518
House
4 Bedrooms
9 Guests
- Oceanfront
- Parking
- Ocean View
- Balcony/Terrace
US $2,088/Night
7 Nights - US $14,613
House
10.0(5 Reviews)
5 Bedrooms
14 Guests
- Hot Tub
- Parking
- Pool
- Kitchen
US $2,028/Night
7 Nights - US $14,196
House
10.0(42 Reviews)
5 Bedrooms
10 Guests
- Private Pool
- Parking
- Pool
- Ocean View
US $1,515/Night
7 Nights - US $10,603
House
9.6(19 Reviews)
3 Bedrooms
6 Guests
- Private Pool
- Parking
- Pool
- Ocean View
US $1,334/Night
7 Nights - US $9,340
House
10.0(5 Reviews)
5 Bedrooms
10 Guests
- Child Friendly
US $1,332/Night
7 Nights - US $9,323
Cottage
1 Bedroom
6 Guests
- Oceanfront
- Ocean View
- Balcony/Terrace
- View
US $1,273/Night
7 Nights - US $8,909
Top-Rated Holiday Rentals with a Pool in Brookhaven
Over 62+ The Best Private Villas and Holiday Rentals in Brookhaven with a Pool
House
10.0(42 Reviews)
4 Bedrooms
8 Guests
- Private Pool
- Hot Tub
- Parking
- Pool
US $697/Night
7 Nights - US $4,881
House
10.0(2 Reviews)
5 Bedrooms
10 Guests
- Private Pool
- Hot Tub
- Pool
- Ocean View
US $972/Night
7 Nights - US $6,806
House
10.0(1 Review)
3 Bedrooms
6 Guests
- Parking
- Pool
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
US $958/Night
7 Nights - US $6,705
House
10.0(1 Review)
4 Bedrooms
10 Guests
- Private Pool
- Hot Tub
- Parking
- Pool
US $796/Night
7 Nights - US $5,572
House
8.8(36 Reviews)
3 Bedrooms
4 Guests
- Private Pool
- Parking
- Pool
- Balcony/Terrace
US $286/Night
7 Nights - US $2,003
US $984/Night
7 Nights - US $6,891
New
House
3 Bedrooms
8 Guests
- Parking
- Pool
- Air Conditioner
- Internet
US $762/Night
7 Nights - US $5,336
US $226/Night
7 Nights - US $1,585
Cottage
10.0(11 Reviews)
3 Bedrooms
6 Guests
- Private Pool
- Oceanfront
- Parking
- Pool
US $1,042/Night
7 Nights - US $7,294
Pet-Friendly Holiday Rentals in Brookhaven
Over 46+ Pet-Friendly Holiday Rentals in or Near Brookhaven
New
Cottage
1 Bedroom
2 Guests
- Parking
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
- Air Conditioner
US $637/Night
7 Nights - US $4,457
House
10.0(24 Reviews)
4 Bedrooms
14 Guests
- Oceanfront
- Parking
- Ocean View
- Balcony/Terrace
US $721/Night
7 Nights - US $5,047
House
10.0(23 Reviews)
4 Bedrooms
8 Guests
- Parking
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
- Air Conditioner
US $709/Night
7 Nights - US $4,964
House
9.8(10 Reviews)
3 Bedrooms
10 Guests
- Hot Tub
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
- Air Conditioner
US $782/Night
7 Nights - US $5,476
House
9.6(63 Reviews)
3 Bedrooms
6 Guests
- Oceanfront
- Parking
- Ocean View
- Balcony/Terrace
US $876/Night
7 Nights - US $6,134
House
9.2(5 Reviews)
4 Bedrooms
10 Guests
- Parking
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
- Air Conditioner
US $381/Night
7 Nights - US $2,664
House
4.0(1 Review)
5 Bedrooms
8 Guests
- Balcony/Terrace
- Internet
- Pet Friendly
- Child Friendly
US $848/Night
7 Nights - US $5,938
House
4 Bedrooms
8 Guests
- Air Conditioner
- Internet
- Pet Friendly
- Child Friendly
US $621/Night
7 Nights - US $4,350
US $734/Night
7 Nights - US $5,138
Large Holiday Rentals and Private Villas in Brookhaven
Over 17+ Large Holiday Rentals and Private Villas in or Near Brookhaven
House
10.0(8 Reviews)
5 Bedrooms
10 Guests
- Oceanfront
- Parking
- Ocean View
- Balcony/Terrace
US $680/Night
7 Nights - US $4,763
House
5.0(3 Reviews)
5 Bedrooms
14 Guests
- Private Pool
- Oceanfront
- Pool
- Ocean View
US $1,552/Night
7 Nights - US $10,864
House
4.3(3 Reviews)
4 Bedrooms
12 Guests
- Private Pool
- Pool
- Kitchen
- Air Conditioner
US $529/Night
7 Nights - US $3,703
House
2.0(1 Review)
4 Bedrooms
10 Guests
- Hot Tub
- View
- Kitchen
- Air Conditioner
US $300/Night
7 Nights - US $2,100
US $560/Night
7 Nights - US $3,920
House
3 Bedrooms
10 Guests
- Pool
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
- Air Conditioner
US $437/Night
7 Nights - US $3,062
House
10.0(1 Review)
3 Bedrooms
10 Guests
- Private Pool
- Oceanfront
- Hot Tub
- Parking
US $296/Night
7 Nights - US $2,072
House
9.6(5 Reviews)
3 Bedrooms
10 Guests
- Private Pool
- Parking
- Pool
- Ocean View
US $1,428/Night
7 Nights - US $9,997
House
4 Bedrooms
10 Guests
- Private Pool
- Oceanfront
- Hot Tub
- Parking
US $1,750/Night
7 Nights - US $12,250
Wheelchair Accessible Holiday Homes in Brookhaven
Over 3+ Wheelchair Accessible Holiday Homes in or Near Brookhaven
Cottage
4.9(13 Reviews)
1 Bedroom
2 Guests
- Kitchen
- Air Conditioner
Wheelchair Accessible- Bedding/Linens
US $150/Night
7 Nights - US $1,050
Hotel
8.4(1004 Reviews)
- Breakfast
- Parking
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
US $170/Night
7 Nights - US $1,189
Apartment
4.0(6 Reviews)
2 Bedrooms
6 Guests
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
- Air Conditioner
- Internet
US $286/Night
7 Nights - US $2,002
Brookhaven Private Villas and Holiday Homes Under $200
Over 4+ Brookhaven Private Villas and Holiday Homes Under $200
Apartment
8.4(11 Reviews)
2 Bedrooms
4 Guests
- Parking
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
- Air Conditioner
US $200/Night
7 Nights - US $1,400
Apartment
5.0(2 Reviews)
2 Bedrooms
6 Guests
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
- Air Conditioner
- Internet
US $195/Night
7 Nights - US $1,365
House
1.0(2 Reviews)
2 Bedrooms
6 Guests
- Kitchen
- Pet Friendly
- Child Friendly
- Bedding/Linens
US $180/Night
7 Nights - US $1,260
Apartment
1 Bedroom
2 Guests
- Pool
Spa- Kitchen
- Air Conditioner
US $135/Night
7 Nights - US $945
Instantly Bookable Holiday Homes in Brookhaven
Over 32+ Instantly Bookable Holiday Homes in or Near Brookhaven
Apartment
10.0(1 Review)
3 Bedrooms
6 Guests
- Oceanfront
- Parking
- Ocean View
- View
US $614/Night
7 Nights - US $4,295
New
House
9.6(5 Reviews)
3 Bedrooms
6 Guests
- Oceanfront
- Parking
- Ocean View
- Balcony/Terrace
US $606/Night
7 Nights - US $4,239
New
House
3 Bedrooms
6 Guests
- Air Conditioner
- Internet
- Child Friendly
- Laundry
US $732/Night
7 Nights - US $5,121
House
4.0(1 Review)
3 Bedrooms
5 Guests
- Air Conditioner
- Internet
- Child Friendly
- Laundry
US $626/Night
7 Nights - US $4,383
House
10.0(1 Review)
4 Bedrooms
8 Guests
- Private Pool
- Oceanfront
- Parking
- Pool
US $811/Night
7 Nights - US $5,678
House
10.0(1 Review)
2 Bedrooms
4 Guests
- Parking
- Kitchen
- Air Conditioner
- Internet
US $650/Night
7 Nights - US $4,547
Cottage
5.2(5 Reviews)
3 Bedrooms
6 Guests
- Oceanfront
- Parking
- Ocean View
- Balcony/Terrace
US $225/Night
7 Nights - US $1,575
House
5.0(2 Reviews)
3 Bedrooms
5 Guests
- Private Pool
- Pool
- Kitchen
- Air Conditioner
US $545/Night
7 Nights - US $3,815
House
3 Bedrooms
6 Guests
- Private Pool
- Pool
- Kitchen
- Air Conditioner
US $995/Night
7 Nights - US $6,965
Book a Last Minute Place to Stay in Brookhaven
About Casai's Private Villas and Holiday Rentals in Brookhaven
Discover more than 143 vacation rentals available in Brookhaven. These rentals, ranging from vacation rentals to Casai Homes and other short-term private accommodations, offer top-notch amenities with unbeatable value, ensuring both comfort and luxury. Enjoy more space and value when you stay at a Casai property in Brookhaven.
Seeking last-minute deals or the best available offers for cottages, condos, private villas, and spacious vacation homes? With Casai in Brookhaven, you can effortlessly compare various deals with just a click. Whether you're looking for a Casai with exceptional swimming pools, hot tubs, pet-friendly options, or large master suite bedrooms equipped with large screen televisions, you'll find a variety of options near Brookhaven. On average, places to stay near Brookhaven offer 622.71 ft², with nightly prices averaging US $770.
With Casai, finding and comparing holiday rentals in Brookhaven is easy and secure, often at a 30-40% discount compared to hotel prices. Simply search for your destination and secure your reservation today.
There are 143 Brookhaven, NY Holiday Rentals
- Prices for a holiday home in Brookhaven start at US $170
- Top rated vacation home in Brookhaven is Location, Location! Beautiful Family Home Centrally Located To Beach & Village
- Most popular short term in Brookhaven is Waterfront & private beach Scandinavian style house near Bellport, NY
- Cheapest place to stay in Brookhaven is 2 bedroom apartment minutes away, by car, from Gambling, Bars, Restaurants, etc
- Most expensive holiday rental in Brookhaven is Large House in Brookhaven Hamlet
Frequently Asked Questions About Brookhaven?
What are the top holiday rentals in Brookhaven?
With numerous options available in Brookhaven, planning to stay in the area? Consider booking a few nights at one of these properties, rated as the Top Holiday Rentals in Brookhaven:
- Location, Location! Beautiful Family Home Centrally Located To Beach & Village
- Cozy home w/heated pool, hot-tub & ping-pong in Bellport Village
- 3 Story Beach Waterview, 3 KING bed, golf putting green!
- Best view of Great South Bay - 4 BR in Bellport, NY. Short walk to village.
- Cozy two-bedroom cottage in Long Island's bucolic Brookhaven Hamlet
- The Hawkins Castle
- Resort-Style Bellport Estate: Private Heated Pool, Spa & Game Room
- Cozy Family-Friendly Beach Retreat with Pool
- Monkey Puzzle Bellport Cottage
- Bellport Inn
How many holiday rentals have private pools in Brookhaven?
Discover a selection of holiday rentals with private pools near Brookhaven with Casai. Experience the epitome of luxury and relaxation in our top-rated villas and holiday homes, where you can enjoy exclusive access to refreshing swimming pools.
Which holiday homes in Brookhaven are best for families?
If you're searching for a family-friendly holiday home in Brookhaven, consider one of the following properties. Each comes highly recommended, with excellent reviews for families or groups staying in Brookhaven:
How many Casai.com holiday rentals are available in Brookhaven?
As of 2026, Casai boasts over 143 properties listed in the Brookhaven area, with more being added continually. By consolidating listings from various websites, Casai provides an extensive selection of the finest Casai properties in Brookhaven.
Nearby Neighborhood (1)
| Neighborhood | Property Count |
|---|---|
| North Bellport Vacation Rentals in Brookhaven, New York | 24 |
